Former Social Security recipient Paul Ryan called out for proposed cuts to gov-assistance programs

PoliticsUSA points out that Rep. Paul Ryan (R-Wis.), whose 2012 budget proposal (PDF) presents significant cuts and alterations to welfare programs, put himself through college using, in part, Social Security benefits he received following the death of his father.

“Representative Paul Ryan is one example of the millions of people whose lives have depended on our social contract with the American people,” writes PoliticsUSA. “Without this benefit, his mother would have had to make even tougher decisions and Representative Paul Ryan may not have been able to pay for his college education.”

Ryan’s background with government assistance was revealed in a July 2010 cover story by Wisconsin Policy Research Institute magazine, which also noted that Ryan was born the day former President Richard Nixon unveiled a $200.8 billion federal budget proposal for the upcoming year, which included a large increase in Social Security payments.

The backstory from WPRI:

One day as a 16 year old, Ryan came upon the lifeless body of his father. Paul Ryan, Sr. had died of a heart attack at age 55, leaving the Janesville Craig High School 10th grader, his three older brothers and sisters and his mother alone. It was Paul who told the family of his father’s death.

With his father’s passing, young Paul collected Social Security benefits until age 18, which he put away for college. To make ends meet, Paul’s mother returned to school to study interior design. His siblings were off at college. Ryan remembers this difficult time bringing him and his mother closer.

Within months, Paul’s maternal grandmother moved into the house. She suffered from Alzheimer’s, and it often fell on young Paul to care for her, including brushing and braiding her hair. Ryan credits his father’s death and the care of his grandmother as giving him first-hand experience as to how social service programs work.

Ryan has frequently spoken about the need for reforming American entitlement programs throughout his political career, and he supports the Republican Study Committee’s proposed Welfare Reform Act of 2011 introduced in March.

Just as he wants to transform Medicare, Ryan also wants to redesign Social Security, transforming it into an investment rather than insurance program, wherein workers under 55 would have the option to move into a new system where they would contribute to personal accounts and then invest “a significant portion” of their payroll taxes into various funds managed by the U.S. government.

In his Roadmap for America’s Future, Ryan predicts that as the personal accounts accumulate wealth, they will eventually replace the current “pay-as-you-go system.”

The chapter in Ryan’s budget proposal on “Strengthening the Social Safety Net” reads:

There is a widely shared consensus in this country in support of a strong safety net for Americans who, through no fault of their own, have fallen on hard times. However, the government programs that make up this safety net are failing both the citizens who rely on them and the taxpayers who fund them. It should not come as a surprise that a system designed in the 1960s is not equipped to deal with the unique pressures of the 21st century.

The safety net should never become a hammock, lulling able-bodied citizens into lives of complacency and dependency. Instead, the aim should be to empower individuals, putting them in stronger position to achieve.

The Associated Press has also pointed to Sen. Scott Brown (R-Mass.) as another former welfare recipient who now advocates for drastic cuts.



Comments

CarmanK 04.20.11

This is the example of “well I had the benefits, and I could have done without them (Ryan put the money away for college)” his mom didn’t have to buy food or pay rent with the money. This is Ryan’s impression of what happens with most SS recipients rather than his being the extraordinary case. My son had a high paying job, when he died his minor children got higher child support pmts than when he was alive (it was used to help shelter and feed the family). I don’t understand a person who benefits from society’s generosity being so determined that others wil not be helped. Whatever happened to “do unto others”?? These creeps just don’t get it. There is no christianity in 2011 conservatism.

Reply
New poll shows mixed messages over U.S. budget crisis | New Mexico Independent 04.22.11

[...] respectively — oppose cutting Medicaid and Medicare. The budget favored by most Republicans, introduced by Rep. Paul Ryan (R-Wis.), would overhaul both programs, ceding control of Medicaid programs to state governments [...]

Reply
puckerupamerica 04.23.11

Why not turn over Medicaid to the states? Let each state independently run their own welfare health benefits system with a block grant in funding from the feds.
As far as the entitlement programs, they need to be reformed! In order for the systems to be there for Ryan and his own kids (and all of ours), there has to be a major shift in structure – the ponzi scheme is coming to an end.
I, for one, would love to have the OPTION to invest my social security funds as I see fit. Choice – gotta love that!
Medicare is going bust even faster than social security! Yes, the younger generation will have to plan to provide for some portion of their health care in their later years. Sorry, but there is no choice in that matter. We are about ten years away from the whole thing going broke.
America provides healthcare for all seniors, all poor, all emergency care, and all children – all on the backs of the half of Americans that actually pay taxes who still have to provide for themselves too. Is it any wonder why these ideas are failing?
Oh, and let’s not get into the debt and deficits that are an evergrowing burden on our credit rating and that it will have to be paid back – or the devaluation of the dollar by the federal reserve ( noticed the price of groceries and gas lately) – or the stubborn unemployment rate that can’t seem to recover – or the growing number of wars/conflicts we find ourselves in – or the escalating border violence with Mexican drug cartels that we’ve forgotten about as caverns of bodies continue to be found – or the deflated housing market that is still in shambles while politicians cry for more lending to people who can’t afford it – or, nevermind…

Reply
Disability Rights Group Protests at Ryan’s Office Over Medicaid by Sofia Resnick | PEOPLEUNLIKEUS 05.04.11

[...] Building in Washington, D.C., Monday to protest the GOP 2012 budget proposal (PDF), authored byRep. Paul Ryan (R-Wis.), which includes approximately 35 percent in funding cuts to Medicaid and a [...]

Reply