First U.S. Senate campaign ad ignites political firestorm
Former Congressman Pete Hoekstra unveiled the first television commercial in the 2012 U.S. Senate race during the Super Bowl, and while he may have been aiming for positive spin, the backlash has been quite pronounced.
Hoekstra is one of six vying for the Republican nomination to unseat Michigan Sen. Debbie Stabenow. His ad features an Asian woman wearing a straw hat, riding a bike near what are implied rice paddies, and speaking broken English. In not-so-subtle terms, the ad implies that Democratic Stabenow is responsible for the U.S. funding China’s explosive growth with U.S. debt.
Hoekstra’s rivals have used the ad — and its mounting criticisms — as an opportunity to slam the former congressman.
“This ad is proof that just because you have a lot of money to throw away doesn’t mean you’re going to win,” said opponent Gary Glenn in an email to The American Independent.
In a general press statement, Glenn, who is the president of the American Family Association of Michigan, said Stabenow and Hoekstra should both be “benched.”
After eighteen years in Washington, Congressman Hoekstra would have more credibility criticizing Debbie Stabenow’s out of control spending if he himself hadn’t voted for the $850 billion Wall Street bailout and Obama’s $192 billion stimulus package and pork barrel boondoggles like the $223 million Bridge to Nowhere, plus raising the debt ceiling to double-digit trillions of dollars. In the Super Bowl, he’d get called for a false start and personal foul on the same play.
Democrats wasted no time in slamming Hoekstra’s new ad. The Michigan Democratic Party released a Web commercial Sunday morning in response to the ad:
“Hoekstra’s attempt at a Hollywood-style makeover is incredibly hypocritical because the fact is, Pete spends a lot,” said Mark Brewer, Chairman of the Michigan Democratic Party. Hoekstra voted for the $700 billion Wall Street bailout and voted for trillions more in deficit spending before quitting Congress to get rich at a Washington, D.C. lobbying firm. Hoekstra is using the big game to play games with Michigan voters, covering up his real record on deficit spending and rigging the rules for the big money insiders he serves.”
In a follow-up press release Monday morning, Democrats slammed Hoekstra on a variety of actions he took in the U.S. House, which they say helped China while hurting Michigan families. The Democrats also pointed out that Stabenow has been a leading voice to challenge China’s currency manipulations, which devalue their money in order to make their goods cheaper upon import to the U.S.
Beyond politics, many people are perceiving the ad to be overtly racist.
One Asian American group slammed Hoekstra on Sunday in a press statement:
Asian & Pacific Islander American Vote – Michigan is deeply disappointed by Pete Hoekstra’s “Debbie-spend-it-now” campaign ad, which plays on harmful stereotypes of Asians speaking broken English and has stereotypical Chinese music playing in the background. It is very disturbing that Mr. Hoekstra’s campaign chose to use harmful and negative stereotypes that intrinsically encourage anti-Asian sentiment.
A Hoekstra spokesperson told the Associated Press the ad was meant to be satirical. But on Sunday night, the AP reports, the staffer wrote on Hoekstra’s Facebook page that those “trying to make this an issue of race demonstrates their total ignorance of job creation policies.”
“As an Asian American working to rebuild Michigan’s fragile economy, I was deeply disappointed in Pete Hoekstra’s Super Bowl ad,” former East Lansing Mayor Sam Singh wrote on his Facebook wall. Singh is currently running for the Michigan state House of Representatives. ”Instead of playing to racial stereotypes that divide us, we need leaders that understand Michigan’s role in the global economy. Michigan’s advance manufacturing base is expanding and jobs are coming back. We need to be attracting international investment and talent at the same time as stabilizing trade imbalances. Political ads like this hurt Michigan and don’t move our economy forward. Michigan deserves better.”
Michigan state Sen. Rick Jones (R-Grand Ledge) said the ad was “not something I would run.” Jones, a former county sheriff and the chair of the Senate Judiciary Committee, told The American Independent he thought Hoekstra’s team ran the ad to get attention — which Jones noted worked because every radio show in Michigan has been talking about it.
Asked specifically about whether he thought it was racist, Jones responded by referring to an incident last week, when Lansing Mayor Virg Bernero, a Democrat, referred to Native Americans opposing his plan to open a casino in Lansing as shooting bows and arrows at him. The mayor also called a spokesperson for the opposition group Chief Chicken Little. The comments sent of a torrent of criticisms.
“I don’t think it was anymore racially insensitive than Virg Bernero’s recent remarks that caused him some media coverage,” Jones said.”I think that political opponents will always make those claims.”
Photo: Former Michigan Congressman Pete Hoekstra, center (source: Flickr/Pete Hoekstra)
Ce piteux spot est, dans le cottxene de la rivalite9 sino-ame9ricaine, somme toute assez banal. On en a vu d’autres e0 l’e9poque de la Guerre Froide ou encore lorsque c’e9tait le Japon qui allait tout rafler. Ce qui est plus de9solant c’est l’ide9e qu’il ve9hicule. Celle du protectionnisme ant-ilibe9ral. De plus dans un Etat qui recommence e0 be9ne9ficier e9conomiquement des exportations. A l’instar de GM, redevenu nume9ro Un de l’auto. En partie gre2ce aux mode8les destine9s e0 l’e9tranger. Y compris e0 des clients chinois.Et puisqu’on e9voque Michigan donc force9ment Detroit avec son ge9ant GM, il surprendra certainement nos ab de9clinologues bb sa soudaine re9surrection. A cet effet, je me permets d’apporter ici quelques extraits d’un excellent dossier paru re9cemment dans l’Equipe et malheureusement non disponible en ligne : DETROIT relance le reave ame9ricain. (Ste9phane Barbe9, mardi le 24/1/12En 2009, General Motors e9tait de9clare9 en faillite. Jeudi, au Salon de Detroit, la marque ame9ricaine est redevenue le premier constructeur mondial redonnant de l’espoir e0 la grande ville du Michigan.[…]Pour General Motors, pre8s de 67 milliards d’euros de dettes accumule9es depuis bientf4t dix ans sont efface9s ; 45 millions d’euros de cre9dits sont de9bloque9s, mais le ge9ant ame9ricain passe sous contrf4le fe9de9ral e0 60%. Le pre9sident des Etats-Unis, Barack Obama, de9cide lui-meame d’une ve9ritable task-force (groupe de travail) pour sauver ce qui peut l’eatre.[…]ab Trop de marques pour pas assez de clients. Je suis arrive9 e0 la teate de GM e0 la sortie de la banqueroute, remarque Dan Akerson, son PDG actuel. Je n’aurais peut-eatre pas fait exactement comme tout ce qui a e9te9 entrepris, mais je dois dire que e7’a e9te9 un sacre9 bon boulot quand meame bb. Jeudi dernier, apre8s le bilan de9finitif de l’exercice 2011, General Motors redevenait le premier constructeur mondial : 9.03 millions de ve9hicules vendus. ab L’objectif e9tait aussi de voir le groupe recommencer e0 embaucher bb, poursuit Akerson. C’est fait, pour le plus grand bonheur de Detroit, la capitale de l’automobile ame9ricaine. Les Chevrolet Volt et Opel Ampera e9lectriques sont assemble9es aux portes de la ville. GM a de9cide9 de fabriquer sa nouvelle Sonic de gamme moyenne dans le Michigan, e0 Lansing. Quel re9tablissement en deux ans et demi ![…]Sans ne9gliger, au contraire, l’immense marche9 ame9ricain qui ne9cessitera toujours des mode8les plus grands pour une cliente8le globalement plus corpulente – Chrysler distribue une Fiat 500 dont les sie8ges sont spe9cialement dimensionne9s pour le marche9 local ( !) -, les constructeurs ame9ricains pre9sentent, aujourd’hui, des voitures aux standards europe9ens, qui ont surtout le grand me9rite de convenir aussi aux nombreux clients… chinois. Cela vaut e9galement pour la cylindre9e des moteurs.ab On se croirait au Salon de Gene8ve, remarquait, dans les alle9es du Salon de Detroit, un vice-pre9sident de Nissan. La Ford Fusion n’a pas de V6 et partout, fleurissent les 1.4 l et 1.6 l turbo Ecoboost, Ecotech… Il y a quinze ans, ici, c’e9tait des moteurs de mobylettes ! bb.L’Ame9rique a pourtant retrouve9 toute sa fierte9 automobile. Et, avec elle, le gofbt de la conqueate comme le confiait un patron de Chevrolet, qui fait de9sormais la chasse aux jeunes : ab S’il y a une voie pour qu’ils tombent amoureux d’une marque automobile comme ils le sont de leur smartphone ou de leur re9seau network, je peux vous rassurer que Chevrolet va la trouver ! bb.A Detroit, au 38e e9tage d’une des tours du Renaissance Center, les plus hautes de la ville, il arrive encore que cela tangue un peu dans le bureau de Dan Akerson. C’est uniquement e0 cause du vent d’hiver. Les ab de9clinistes bb auront certainement besoin de longues explications sur ce ab miracle bb qui n’en est pas un. Pour les ame9ricanophiles, panipwoble8me : American Spirit !